The Twin Paradox: Why it is Required by Relativity
نویسنده
چکیده
The Twin Paradox is one of the most well known and debated paradoxes associated with Relativity theory. Opponents challenge Relativity theory on the grounds that the Twin Paradox reveals an underlying flaw in the theory. Such opponents feel that the existence of a paradox, in and of itself, is sufficient to disqualify the theory. Supporters explain the paradox by introducing the concept of acceleration into the theory, thus limiting the interpretation to the twin that was undergoing the force of acceleration. However, both interpretations fail to explain why Relativity requires the paradox, which is actually the result of using a length based model to interpret wavelength based observations. Here we show the proper use and interpretation of wavelength based observations using wavelength based equations, and how the mistaken use of length based equations results in time dilation, length contraction, and the Twin Paradox.
منابع مشابه
Epistemic Relativity Theory (Part I): Time and Distance Transformations
Einstein's theory of special relativity (SR) theory dictates, as a force majeure, an ontic view, according to which relativity is a true state of nature. For example, the theory’s solution to the famous twin paradox prescribes the "traveling" twin returns truly and verifiably younger than the "staying" twin, thereby implying the “traveling” twin returns to the future. I propose an epistemic vie...
متن کاملInformation Relativity Theory (Part I): Time and Distance Transformations
Einstein's theory of special relativity (SR) theory dictates, as a force majeure, an ontic view, according to which relativity is a true state of nature. For example, the theory’s solution to the famous twin paradox prescribes the "traveling" twin returns truly and verifiably younger than the "staying" twin, thereby implying the “traveling” twin returns to the future. I propose an epistemic vie...
متن کاملDetecting Absolute Motion
The famous twin paradox of the Special Theory of Relativity by Einstein (1905) is revisited and revised. This paradox is not a paradox in the true sense of a paradox but a reflection of a misunderstanding of the problem and the Principle of Relativity. The currently accepted solution to this takes into account the accelerations and deceleration of the traveling twin thus introducing an asymmetr...
متن کاملA twin paradox for ‘clever’ students
We discuss the twin paradox or the clock paradox under the small velocity approximation of special relativity. In this paper the traveller twin of the standard twin parable sets out with a non-relativistic speed for the trip leaving behind the stay-at-home one on earth and continues up to a distance and finally returns home with the same speed when the siblings can compare their ages or their i...
متن کاملSymmetrical Experiments to Test the Clock Paradox
The kinetic and dynamic theories to resolve the clock paradox of the special theory of relativity are critically reviewed. It has been shown that the argument based on asymmetry is invalid and the signal-counting scheme is not the correct explanation of differential aging. The clock paradox is restated in the symmetrical twin brothers (2-J) and quadruplet brothers (4-J) experiments. These exper...
متن کامل